Single Embryo Beat Double Embryo Transfer in IVF
WEDNESDAY, Dec. 22 (HealthDay News) -- Women who undergo
in-vitro fertilization (IVF) are almost five times more likely to
give birth to a single healthy baby following the implantation of a
single embryo than are women who choose to have two embryos
implanted at the same time, an international team of experts has
The finding comes from an analysis of data involving nearly
1,400 women who participated in one of eight different embryo
transfer studies. Approximately half of the women underwent
procedures involving the single transfer of an embryo, while the
other half underwent a double embryo procedure.
Overall, the study authors noted that, relative to a double
embryo transfer, a single embryo transfer appears to significantly
increase the chances of carrying a baby to a full term of more than
In addition to lowering the risk for premature birth, a single
embryo transfer also appeared to lower the risk for delivering a
low birth weight baby, D.J. McLernon, a research fellow with the
medical statistics team in the section of population health at the
University of Aberdeen in the United Kingdom, and colleagues
reported in the Dec. 22 online edition of
"Our review should be useful in informing decision making regarding the number of embryos to transfer in IVF," the authors wrote in their report. They added that their observations could offer practical guidance to would-be mothers and doctors who are eager to foster optimal conditions for a successful pregnancy, while at the same time hoping to avoid the increased health risks associated with IVF procedures that give rise to multiple-birth pregnancies.
The authors concluded that doctors should advise patients to
choose the single embryo transfer option over what appears to be
the less optimal double embryo transfer option.
At face value, the data seemed to suggest that the double embryo
transfer option does, in fact, offer the mother much better odds
for giving birth to a single healthy baby. While among study
participants just 27 percent of single embryo transfer procedures
resulted in the birth of a healthy baby, that figure rose to 42
percent of double embryo transfer births, the investigators
However, that spread was narrowed considerably when the authors
focused on those women undergoing an initial single embryo transfer
procedure who then underwent a second single implant (of a frozen
embryo). That scenario (in which, in essence, two single embryo
transfers are conducted in sequence) prompted a 38 percent success
rate -- a figure just 4 percent shy of the 42 percent success rate
attributed to two embryos being implanted simultaneously.
What's more, the researchers further found that a single embryo
transfer offered women an 87 percent better chance of carrying a
baby to full-term than a double embryo transfer.
In addition, the single embryo transfer entailed just one-third
of the risk (compared with the double embryo transfer procedure)
that the mother would ultimately deliver a low birth weight
Commenting on the study, Dr. Laurel Stadtmauer, an associate
professor of obstetrics and gynecology and IVF associate director
of the Eastern Virginia Medical School Jones Institute for
Reproductive Medicine in Norfolk, Va., described the current effort
as "very convincing."
"There is a consensus that there is a high number of multiple births from IVF, and we're all doing everything we can to reduce that rate of birth because we know that premature birth and multiple births do lead to a higher risk for the babies and for the mother," she explained.
"And this certainly shows that cumulatively you can often achieve a much better outcome with two separate single embryo transfers compared with one double embryo transfer -- which would mean a much lower chance of a multiple pregnancy and all the related complications," Stadtmauer continued.
"However, while a single embryo transfer is appropriate for a number of women it's not appropriate in all women. Because while in young women or women with good prognostic factors a single embryo transfer can be very successful, in women over the age of 38 or women with low chances of pregnancy and poor prognostic factors, there would be a significant reduction in success compared to a double pregnancy transfer," she cautioned.
"There are also financial and emotional costs to undergoing a procedure twice, particularly as there is always a risk for failure. So not all women are easily convinced to choose the single transfer option," Stadtmauer added. "So while it's definitely the future, it's not for everybody. But the better we get at selecting which embryos have the highest chances of implanting, the better we can get at directing patients towards elective single embryo transfers."
For more on in-vitro fertilization, visit the
U.S. National Library of Medicine.
Copyright © 2010
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.