Trained Labrador Can Sniff Out Colon Cancer, Researchers
MONDAY, Jan. 31 (HealthDay News) -- With powers of smell far
superior to those of humans, dogs can sniff out buried earthquake
victims. They can unearth hidden bombs or drugs. They can also
apparently detect colorectal cancer, Japanese researchers
Researchers from Kyushu University and colleagues report that a
specially trained 8-year-old female Labrador retriever named Marine
is able to detect colorectal cancer among patients with up to 98
A graduate of the St. Sugar Cancer-Sniffing Dog Training Center
in Chiba, Japan, the dog was initially trained for water rescue and
could already detect 12 types of cancer in patients' breath samples
before she joined the colorectal cancer study, the researchers
The goal of the study was to find out whether odor can become an
effective tool in colorectal cancer screening, according to lead
researcher Dr. Hideto Sonoda, from the department of surgery at the
Postgraduate School of Medicine at Kyushu University in
The report is published in the Jan. 31 online edition of the
For the study, Sonoda's group collected samples of stool and
exhaled breath from 40 patients with colorectal cancer and also
from 320 healthy people. "The tests were conducted from November to
June, because the dog's concentration tends to decrease during the
hot summer season," Sonoda noted.
The dog was able to distinguish cancerous samples from
noncancerous samples in 33 of 36 breath tests and in 37 of 38 stool
tests, the researchers found. "Moreover, canine scent judgment even
appeared to be highly accurate for early-stage colorectal cancer,"
In contrast, fecal occult blood screening -- a simple,
non-invasive test for colon cancer -- picks up early-stage disease
in only one out of 10 cases, the study noted.
Based on their findings, the researchers say the canine's
evaluation of breath samples was accurate 95 percent of the time
and her stool sample evaluation was accurate 98 percent of the
time, compared with colonoscopy, which is the "gold standard" for
identifying colon cancer.
In fact, the dog was able to identify cancers even when smokers
and people with other stomach problems were included in the test,
the researchers noted.
The tests were repeated three times, Sonoda said. "The results
of all tests were correct, thereby suggesting that a specific
cancer scent indeed exists," he said.
The researchers also took breath and stool samples from patients
with breast, stomach and prostate cancer. "Canine scent judgment
yielded correct answers for these cancers as well, suggesting that
common scents may exist among various cancer types," Sonoda
While dogs seem to be able to pick-up the "smell" of cancer,
using dogs as a screening tool is not the ultimate goal, he
Scent ability and concentration vary between different dogs and
also with the same dog on different days, Sonoda pointed out.
"Moreover, each dog can only conduct tests for a maximum of 10
years. So it is difficult to introduce canine scent judgment into
clinical practice," he said.
For these reasons, it is necessary to identify the
cancer-specific organic compounds detected by dogs and to develop
an early cancer detection sensor that can be substituted for a
dog's judgment, Sonoda said.
"We hope that the results of the present study will provide encouragement for the development of cancer detection and solving the biological character of cancer using odor material," he said.
Commenting on the study, Dr. Ted Gansler, director of medical
content at the American Cancer Society, said that "this study adds
to a small number of other published articles showing similar
results regarding bladder, lung and breast cancers," and to a
recent conference presentation regarding prostate cancer.
"In addition to these studies, there have been several anecdotal reports of patients whose pet dogs seemed attracted to or upset by skin cancers," he added.
Although the idea of dogs recognizing cancer might initially
seem difficult for some people to believe, it also seems
biologically plausible, Gansler said.
"We know that trained dogs can distinguish the scent of one person from another person. Dogs can also be trained to recognize very low concentrations of explosives or illegal drugs in the air. Scientists have already identified some of the chemical differences between normal and malignant tissues, so it is not surprising that some dogs can also recognize these differences," he said.
Some might wonder whether it is time to use dogs in the clinic
for cancer screening, Gansler said. "However, much more research
will be needed before we can seriously think about dogs assuming
roles in cancer screening similar to their current ones in law
enforcement," he said.
One limitation is that the dog in this study did not reliably
recognize any abnormal scent from precancerous polyps, although it
was not specifically trained to do so, Gansler said. "In contrast,
some colon cancer tests such as colonoscopy can accurately
recognize these polyps so they can be removed by the doctor in
order to prevent colon cancer before it is fully developed."
The next step is to discover the specific chemicals associated
with colon cancer, or with other types of cancers, Gansler said.
"Once that is done, scientists will try to develop laboratory tests
that detect these chemicals as potential methods for cancer
Another expert, Dr. Floriano Marchetti, an assistant professor
of clinical surgery and director of the Colon and Rectal Surgery
Residency Program at the University of Miami Miller School of
Medicine, said that "the direction should be to stimulate research
in finding the organic compound that the dog reacts to."
If one could develop a simple screening test, it could be useful
in getting more people screened for colon cancer, he said. "In this
country, any type of screening for colorectal cancer is in the
order of 40 to 45 percent. Something like this, if it were simple,
would be beneficial."
For more information on colon/rectal cancer, visit the
American Cancer Society.
Copyright © 2011
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.