Placebo Effect May Work in Reverse02/16/11
WEDNESDAY, Feb. 16 (HealthDay News) -- Everyone's heard of the
placebo effect: when you take a sugar pill but believe it is
medicine, it tends to work. Now a new study suggests that the
opposite may also be true.
In the study, people's pain levels fluctuated greatly with their
belief that they either were or were not receiving a powerful
painkiller, remifentanil -- even though the dose of the drug did
not change throughout the experiment.
Pain levels shot up, in fact, soon after participants were told
that the drug had been discontinued, something experts call the
The findings suggest that doctors may need to deal with their
patients' beliefs about a treatment, whether positive or negative,
"Our study provides evidence that the expectation of a drug's effect critically influences its therapeutic efficacy," said lead researcher Dr. Ulrike Bingel, from the department of neurology at the University of Hamburg Medical Center in Germany.
"We found that positive treatment expectancy substantially enhanced -- doubled -- the analgesic benefit of remifentanil. In contrast, negative treatment expectancy completely abolished remifentanil's painkilling effect," she said.
"Intriguingly, this very same pattern was found in the activation of those brain areas that are well known to be involved in the intensity of pain," Bingel added.
The study, which also involved researchers from Oxford
University in the U.K., is published in the Feb. 16 issue of
Science Translational Medicine.
For the study, Bingel's team gave 22 healthy volunteers the
opioid painkiller remifentanil and then tested its effect by
changing the patient's expectations of the treatment.
The participants were first placed inside an MRI brain scanner,
and an intravenous line used to administer the drug was attached.
The researchers then applied heat to each volunteer's leg to the
point of causing pain, and set the heat at such a level that each
participant initially rated their pain at 70 out of 100. At the
same time, they gave the volunteers remifentanil but did not tell
them they were doing so.
As would be expected with the powerful drug taking effect, the
average level of self-reported pain participants felt declined a
bit, falling from 66 points down to 55 on a 100-point scale.
The researchers then told the volunteers that the remifentanil
was starting (even though they had already been getting the drug).
The result: participants' average pain levels fell dramatically, to
To test the "nocebo" effect, Bingel's team then told the
volunteers they were stopping the drug and they might start to feel
more pain again -- a lie, since they continued to administer the
same level of the painkiller.
At this point, the volunteers' self-reported pain levels shot
back up to an average of 64 points -- that is, the pain was as
great as if they had received no pain relief at all.
In each stage of the experiment, MRI scans showed different
brain activity in responses to the volunteer's varied expectations
of pain or pain relief, the researchers said. Specifically, in
people who were primed to think they were getting the painkiller,
areas of the brain were engaged that made it more difficult for
pain signals to reach the brain or spinal cord, the researchers
Bingel believes that the data "opens a new avenue of research,"
linking up drugs with patients' personalities and expectations in
the context of specific medical conditions.
The findings also have implications for clinical practice, she
said. "We believe that the beliefs, expectations and previous
experiences with drug treatments should be more systematically
assessed and integrated [by doctors] to optimize the overall
One expert agreed.
Dr. Fatta B. Nahab, an assistant professor of neurology at the
University of Miami's Miller School of Medicine, said the study
shows that patient expectation can have an impact on outcomes.
"What this teaches doctors is that you have to do a great job of educating patients about their treatments, and also limit false or negative expectations," he said. "If we do that our outcomes would be much better and, I think, patients would be more satisfied with the treatments they are getting."
The findings may also point to ways of harnessing the brain to
"People have talked about bottling the placebo response," Nahab said. "This is our first indication of how we might bottle that placebo response. If we could go into some of these regions and figure out if we could change them, we might be able to enhance the efficacy of any medication or any treatment, and that's really the huge part of this work."
For more information on pain management, visit the
U.S. National Library of Medicine.
Copyright © 2011
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.