GPs Lack Accuracy in Spotting Skin Cancers:
MONDAY, May 16 (HealthDay News) -- When general doctors refer
patients to a specialist to investigate a suspicious skin lesion,
it's more often another lesion that turns out to be cancerous, a
new study finds.
The findings suggest non-dermatologists might benefit from
increased education on skin cancer detection, the study authors
"We were very surprised to see the very high number of incidentally detected skin cancers," said study author Dr. Daniel G. Federman, a professor of medicine at Yale University School of Medicine in New Haven, Conn. "However, when we thought about it, we were not surprised that having one suspicious lesion may be a marker of an increased rate of skin cancer elsewhere. Medicine has known for quite some time that having one skin cancer is a risk factor for the development of future skin cancers."
Using medical records of 400 patients referred by a
non-dermatologist to the dermatology service at Veterans Affairs
Connecticut Health System, researchers analyzed the proportion of
suspicious lesions identified by non-dermatologists that were found
to be malignant compared to lesions first noticed at the
Only 22 percent of the patients had a so-called index lesion --
the lesion that prompted the referral to a dermatologist -- that
tested positive for cancer, the study said. But 55 percent of an
additional 111 biopsied lesions not noticed during the general
doctors' initial exams were malignant.
"It is possible that with the multitude of tasks needing to be performed in primary care, full-body skin examinations may be omitted or not stressed," Federman said.
Skin cancer is the most common malignancy in the United States,
according to the Skin Cancer Foundation, with more than 3.5 million
cases diagnosed each year in more than two million people.
The study, published May 16 in
Archives of Dermatology, involved mostly white men, whose average age was about 78. Federman acknowledged that the narrow grouping may have been a limitation, since the elderly are more likely to develop skin cancer than younger people.
More than 220 of the 400 suspicious lesions (56 percent) that
originally prompted a referral were considered non-cancerous by the
dermatologist and required no biopsy. Eighty-eight of the 176
lesions needing biopsies tested positive for cancer, meaning only
about one-fifth of initially questionable lesions were
Nearly half of all skin cancers identified were not the referral
lesion, the study said, while nearly 10 percent of the lesions
discovered incidentally were melanomas, the most dangerous form of
the disease, which account for 75 percent of skin cancer
Federman, also firm chief in primary care at VA Connecticut
Healthcare System, noted that the study was not designed to
determine whether the non-dermatologist performed a full-body skin
examination looking for other cancers during the initial exam.
Federman and his team noted that teledermatology, the practice
of diagnosing suspicious skin lesions using digital images, can be
useful in geographic areas with few dermatologists or when a
patient may be physically unable to visit a dermatologist.
But the study results suggest that patients with questionable
lesions also should ideally receive a full-body examination by a
dermatologist, he said.
"If a non-dermatologist finds one lesion on a patient that he or she is considering photographing for transmission, he or she should check other parts of the body and send multiple images -- not feel limited to just one," he said. "There are some non-dermatologists who do their own skin biopsies in the office . . . they should improve their diagnostic skills and either make sure they perform a thorough, full-body skin examination, and when possible refer to a dermatologist."
Dr. Darrell S. Rigel, an educational spokesman for the Skin
Cancer Foundation, said the study results are consistent with what
he and most other dermatologists see on a daily basis -- that many
malignancies are detected only after a primary care physician has
already screened a patient.
"This is not to disrespect any non-dermatologists," said Rigel, also clinical professor of dermatology at New York University Langone Medical Center. "The reality is, we're just experts at it because we do it every day. But obviously this is an important thing and if they can't get the appropriate amount of education for this, it's going to continue to happen."
The Skin Cancer Foundation publishes a comprehensive fact list
Copyright © 2011
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.