Crouse Health Online: Wellness is just a click away.
Share Share
  |  Connect with Us: 
large
med
small
Text Size
 

Health News



CT Heart Scans No Benefit to Patients Without Symptoms

CT Heart Scans No Benefit to Patients Without Symptoms

05/23/11

MONDAY, May 23 (HealthDay News) -- For people who show no symptoms of heart disease, there is little short-term benefit to having their heart vessels scanned for plaque buildup, a new study suggests.

While interesting, new technologies such as CT angiography haven't demonstrated in clinical trials that they are useful for asymptomatic patients. Moreover, CT angiography is not needed to get the best treatment and the best prevention for heart disease, said lead researcher Dr. John W. McEvoy, a heart specialist at Johns Hopkins University.

"In asymptomatic patients, while it makes sense in some respects to want to know if there is any heart disease, studies to date don't demonstrate that knowing whether or not you have coronary disease makes any difference to what can be done to change the outcome," he said.

It's patients with symptoms such as angina or shortness of breath who benefit from such scans and aggressive treatment, McEvoy noted.

"If someone has risk factors for heart disease, but no symptoms, the doctor would be best served by doing a good physical, taking a history and measuring risk factors and treating those risk factors," he said.

"Patients, and everybody in general, tend to think that the new fancy technology may be the best test they can have to know whether or not they have heart disease," he said. "But it doesn't matter whether or not you have mild heart disease, what matters is whether or not you are living a good lifestyle."

This includes reducing blood pressure, lowering cholesterol, eating healthfully, not smoking and staying active, McEvoy said.

The report was published in the May 23 online edition of the Archives of Internal Medicine.

For the study, McEvoy's group collected data on 1,000 patients who had no symptoms of heart disease who underwent CT angiography. These individuals were taking part in a screening program in South Korea.

The researchers compared these people with another group of similar individuals who had not had CT angiography.

None of the patients in either group had chest pain or any other symptoms of heart disease. These men and women were an average of 50 years old, the researchers noted. In addition, people in both groups were given standard care advice on how to lower their risk for heart disease.

McEvoy's team found that 215 of the people who underwent CT angiography had plaque buildup. These patients, based on this finding, were more likely to receive aggressive care.

In fact, they were 10 times more likely to have an exercise stress test, a nuclear medicine scan or cardiac catheterization, compared with those who did not have CT angiography, McEvoy's group noted.

In addition, those who had plaque buildup were three times more likely to be prescribed a cholesterol-lowering drug and four times more likely to be taking aspirin to thin their blood to prevent clots.

After 18 months, one person who had CT angiography developed chest pain called unstable angina, and one person who had not had CT angiography died of a heart attack, the study authors noted.

McEvoy said 18 months might be too short a time to see whether the aggressive treatment given patients who underwent CT angiography was worthwhile.

"You could make an argument that it should. Maybe over five to 10 years there might have been a difference. But even if we found a difference, we wouldn't know for sure if the CT angiogram was the cause of an improved outcome, because this was not a randomized trial," he said. "This was a preliminary study."

Dr. Gregg C. Fonarow, a professor of cardiology at the University of California, Los Angeles, said the use of CT angiography in asymptomatic patients has not shown a proven benefit.

"Cardiovascular risk assessment and noninvasive detection of atherosclerosis in asymptomatic individuals using CT angiography has been adopted into clinical practice by certain physicians without clear evidence that clinical outcomes are improved with this testing," he said.

While screening CT angiography was associated with moderately higher use of aspirin and statin therapy in those with positive scans, there was an increase in non-guideline-based testing and other procedures without any difference in outcomes in those with CT angiography screening compared with those without screening, Fonarow said.

"The use of CT angiography in asymptomatic individuals may expose patients to potentially unnecessary radiation, may result in additional non-guideline-based testing and revascularization procedures, and has yet to be demonstrated to improve clinical outcomes," he added.

More information

For more details on heart disease, visit the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.

Copyright © 2011 HealthDay. All rights reserved.

Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.

OF INTEREST:
 

Latest News

Crouse Hospital Appoints Chief Information Officer
more >

MedEx Bedside Prescription Delivery Service

Free service offers convenience, patient education at discharge.
more >

CrouseSports Express After-Hours Ortho Care

Immediate care of orthopedic injuries in kids and adults.
more >

Weight Loss Surgery

Is it right for you? Attend a free information seminar held twice monthly.
more >

Quality at Crouse

See how Crouse Hospital strives to provide the best in patient care.
more >

Cheer Up That Special Someone

Say get well or welcome a new arrival with a gift purchased right at Crouse.

more >

Make an Online Donation Now

Your donation of any amount helps support Crouse services & programs in a meaningful way.
more >

Shop Online Now

Say get well, thinking of you or welcome new baby with a unique gift from the Crouse Gift Shop.

more >