Deaths Up, Care Levels Down at Teaching Hospitals in
MONDAY, July 11 (HealthDay News) -- The dog days of summer are a
perfect time for hitting the beach. But a summer visit to your
local teaching hospital?
Perhaps not so much, caution researchers who report that such
institutions tend to suffer a dip in efficiency and a spike in
patient deaths whenever they undergo the massive medical resident
turnover that typically ensues every July.
The observation stems from an analysis of 39 studies that looked
at a phenomenon commonly known as the "July Effect." The term
refers to the specific time of year when experienced medical
residents in training depart their assigned teaching hospital, to
be replaced by fresh-faced but less experienced interns.
"Our study is a signal that there is increased risk at this time," noted study author Dr. John Q. Young, associate program director of the residency training program within the department of psychiatry at the University of California, San Francisco's School of Medicine. "That's the bottom line, and it's something that patients should be aware of."
"However, at the same time, patients should not delay care because of this concern," Young stressed. "They should always seek the care they need whenever they need it. But I would say that this concern makes it important that patients try to include a family member or a friend in the process. You should bring them with you to the hospital, so they can advocate for you, and not hesitate to ask to speak to the experienced attending physician that will always be there overseeing the team."
Young and his colleagues report their findings in the July 12
online edition of the
Annals of Internal Medicine.
At issue, say the authors, is a longstanding concern over the
summer season disruption to a teaching hospital's medical
effectiveness that can occur when large groups of well-experienced
trainees exit a facility just as "newbie" medical trainees are
pouring in. Such changeovers involve about 100,000 medical staff in
the United States and 32,000 in Europe each year, Young and his
Concerns revolve around the new staff's general unfamiliarity
with the intricate workings of a complex hospital environment, as
well as their relative lack of experience that may leave them
unprepared for the demands of a high-paced clinical setting.
Analyzing the possible consequences to patient health, the study
team sifted through the results of 39 English-language studies
(mostly American) that were conducted between 1989 and 2010.
The team focused on the July rate of fatalities, medical
complications and medical errors at teaching hospitals, as well as
overall hospital efficiency variables such as patient
hospitalization times, medical costs and operating room time,
compared to other months.
The results: Patient fatality rates tended to go up during July
staff changeovers, while care efficiency went down. And that, the
research team concluded, means that the "July Effect" is real.
However, differences in the way the 39 studies were conducted
made it impossible for the authors to determine the exact causes
for such trends, and the degree to which patient care might be
compromised. In addition, they could not pinpoint which types of
teaching hospitals are the most vulnerable to staff turnover.
"There really needs to be more and better studies of this issue -- ones that control for the important variables and factors involved, and that look at things like morbidity, surgical complications, infections, that sort of thing," Young said.
"But I would say that hospitals themselves already take this problem quite seriously," Young added, "and many take specific steps to deal with the risks. [These include] testing the competency and clinical skills of new residents when they take up new positions, and making sure that the level of responsibility they are given is appropriate. Many have made an effort to enhance supervision, control the growth of caseloads new residents are assigned, and provide better orientation. So, attention is being paid."
Experts also suggests preventing resident fatigue and staggering
start schedules for trainees, so the most experienced residents
don't all leave at once.
On his part, Dr. David Dunkin, an assistant professor of
pediatrics in the division of pediatric gastroenterology at the
Mount Sinai School of Medicine in New York City, concurred that
teaching hospitals are aware of the "July Effect" and are taking
practical steps to minimize associated risks.
"This is a real issue," said Dunkin. "But I don't think that patients should be nervous about this."
"I say that because there are a lot of layers in an academic situation," he explained. "Yes, in July experienced trainees go and less experienced trainees come. But the hospital faculty doesn't turn over. And there are constant senior levels of supervision that remain in place. And that means that the July turnover is counterbalanced by an increased vigilance, in which senior level people are watching the new people very closely."
That said, Dunkin expanded on Young's advice as to steps
patients can take to improve their hospital experience, regardless
of when they might visit a teaching hospital.
"Yes, patients should bring someone with them if they can," he said. "And also be prepared to bring in with them anything that will make it easier to make sure that there will be no misunderstandings concerning their medical history. A copy of any records, if they have had medical illnesses. Or even a letter from their primary care physician or specialist stating what their medical issues are and what medications they are on. That kind of succinct summary reduces the chance of an error being made year-round."
For more on teaching hospitals, visit the
Association of American Medical Colleges.
Copyright © 2011
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.