More Evidence Minorities in U.S. Get Poorer Hospital
THURSDAY, Oct. 6 (HealthDay News) -- The United States'
so-called "worst" hospitals are home to a significantly larger pool
of elderly, poor and minority patients than are the nation's better
quality/lower cost institutions, new research says.
While elderly black Americans constitute nearly 7 percent of the
patients in the country's 122 "best" hospitals, they make up 15
percent of patients among the nation's 178 "worst" health care
facilities, the investigators found.
Elderly Hispanics and Medicaid patients also appear to be
over-represented in financially strapped hospitals that were found
to have relatively poor health outcomes and higher fatality
The study team also warns that the situation among the country's
most beleaguered facilities is poised to get worse, given the
reward system outlined in the new U.S. health care law, which will
empower Medicare and Medicaid to cut payments to hospitals that
don't meet designated quality standards.
"What we're taking about is a new regime in which we're going to see big cuts in payments from Medicare, which is the biggest payer of hospital care in this country," said study lead author Dr. Ashish K. Jha, an associate professor in the department of health policy and management at the Harvard School of Public Health.
"And anytime you have this kind of change there are going to be winners and losers," Jha added. "The hospitals that are most at risk for coming out on the losing end -- the ones that are already faring poorly -- are also those who care for the most vulnerable populations."
Jha and his colleagues present their findings in the October
For the study, the authors looked at patient populations and
care quality at about 3,200 hospitals across the United States.
The hospitals that ranked in the top quarter in terms of
providing the highest quality of care and the lowest quarter in
terms of cost were deemed the "best." The so-called "worst"
hospitals fell into the lowest quarter in terms of care quality and
the highest quarter in terms of cost.
The difference between a "best" and "worst" designation can be
the difference between life and death for someone with heart
disease or pneumonia, the study authors said. For example,
heart-attack patients were found to face a 7 percent to 10 percent
higher risk for dying at one of the worst hospitals, compared to
similar patients at the best.
The authors observed that the best hospitals were more often in
the Northeast, and were more likely to be non-profit facilities
outfitted with more state-of- the-art equipment for such problems
as cardiac illness.
The worst institutions were more likely to be for-profit or
public facilities, and were more likely to be located in the
In addition to the doubling of black patient populations in the
worst institutions, the study authors also noted that while
Hispanics accounted for just 1 percent of the patient pool in the
best hospitals, they made up 4 percent in the worst. Similarly,
while Medicaid patients accounted for just 15 percent of all
patients in the best facilities, they constituted 23 percent among
"Now I want to stress that there is nothing inherent about caring for poor or minority patients that should make it so that it is inevitable that they be subject to lower-quality care," said Jha. "But the truth is that we see it over and over again."
Dr. Ali Salim, an attending surgeon and program director of the
General Surgery Residency Educational Program at Cedars-Sinai
Medical Center in Los Angeles, expressed little surprise with the
"First off, it should be said that these points made in this study are all just associations," he cautioned. "There is no cause and effect that can be gleaned by their observation.
"But this is definitely an important and interesting study," added Salim, who is also a trauma surgeon. "And the findings conform closely to what we see out there in practice. I can say for sure that we see it in trauma care, among those safety-net hospitals that care for a higher proportion of minorities. These facilities tend to have worse outcomes regardless of their insurance status or their race."
A Johns Hopkins School of Medicine report published in the
Archives of Surgery last month highlights Salim's point,
concluding that patients of all races face worse outcomes and a
greater risk for death when treated at trauma centers that serve a
higher proportion of minority patients.
For more on minorities and health care disparities, visit the
U.S. National Association of Public Hospitals...d
Copyright © 2011
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.