Genes May Make Quitting Tougher for Smokers12/02/11
THURSDAY, Dec. 1 (HealthDay News) -- Despite decades of public
health efforts aimed at snuffing out cigarette smoking, 20 percent
of Americans still light up. New research suggests it might be
because of their genes.
While anti-smoking campaigns are credited with slicing cigarette
use drastically over the past 40 years -- from 42 percent of all
Americans in 1965 to just under 20 percent in 2010 -- the number of
people who haven't been able to nix their nicotine habit has
flatlined in recent years, according to the U.S. Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention.
Two out of three adults who smoke want to quit, a CDC report out
earlier this month said, and more than half (52 percent) had
attempted to quit in the past year.
The authors of the new study, released online in advance of
publication in an upcoming print issue of
Demography, say new tactics may be needed to help the remaining smokers.
"Federal and social policies may be somewhat less effective now because maybe the composition of those at risk [those who smoke] has changed," said study co-author Fred Pampel, a professor of sociology at the University of Colorado at Boulder and a research associate at the Institute of Behavioral Science there. Those who can quit easily have probably done so, the authors said.
Study lead author Jason Boardman, an associate professor of
sociology, said anti-smoking messages, higher taxes and
restrictions on smoking have made a difference. "But for hard-core
smokers, there may be something else going on," he said. That
"something else" is likely genetics, he added.
The researchers drew this conclusion after analyzing the smoking
habits between 1960 and 1980 of nearly 600 pairs of twins who
answered an extensive health questionnaire -- 363 were identical
sets of twins and 233 were fraternal twins. Identical twins come
from the same fertilized egg before it splits into two embryos and
they share the same genes or DNA, while fraternal twins come from
two separately fertilized egg cells and only share some genetic
In the identical twin group, 65 percent of both individuals quit
within a two-year period of each other, while only 55 percent of
the fraternal twins quit within that same stretch of time.
"The logic here is that the identical twins share genes, so if they act alike it probably reflects a genetic component," said Pampel.
The new research adds to a growing body of literature suggesting
there is probably a substantial genetic influence when it comes to
nicotine addiction, said Dr. Aditi Satti, an assistant professor of
medicine and director of the smoking cessation program at Temple
University Hospital in Philadelphia. But scientists are still
trying to pinpoint the gene or genes involved, she said.
"There has not been one specific gene linked to nicotine addiction," said Satti.
She noted that while numbers of smokers have decreased over the
years, smoking is up among women and black Americans, possibly
another clue as to who is genetically at risk. Inner city, low
socioeconomic and less-educated populations are more likely to be
smokers, too, Satti added.
"I think the combo of finding better medications and educating people, even if doctors just spend five minutes talking with your patient about smoking, will lead to higher quit rates," Satti said.
Boardman said a policy shift might be in line. Instead of
government anti-smoking campaigns focusing on high taxes and
splashy advertisements, he said current smokers may discover more
success using medication aimed at nicotine addiction, as well as
"I'd argue that nicotine replacement therapies may be far more effective with existing smokers still trying to quit than the posters showing images of smokers that are not cool. Behavior-changing efforts -- I don't think that's going to help the two-pack a day smokers," said Boardman, who is also a research associate at the Institute of Behavioral Science.
Smoking-related diseases lead to approximately 443,000 deaths a
year in the United States, including babies born prematurely to
women who smoke while pregnant and those harmed by secondhand
smoke, according to the American Lung Association.
Satti is concerned that cigarette addiction isn't taken
seriously enough by some.
"Maybe we don't see smoking as being as important as alcohol and drug addiction, but I'm a pulmonologist and I see chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), emphysema and lung cancer every day," she said. "And we know tobacco smoke is linked to cardiovascular disease and stroke. It's one of the most preventable things you can do. If you quit smoking, you'll see a huge impact on health."
The American Cancer Society can help you determine if you need
Copyright © 2011
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.