Pot Use Could Double Risk of Car Crash, Research
THURSDAY, Feb. 9 (HealthDay News) -- Getting behind the wheel
within three hours after using marijuana nearly doubles a driver's
risk of having an accident, a large new research review finds.
The risk is especially high for fatal crashes, and the risk is
only a little less than that of people who drive drunk, Canadian
"On the whole, alcohol increases the risk of a crash at a higher level than cannabis [marijuana]," said lead researcher Mark Asbridge, an associate professor in the community health and epidemiology department at Dalhousie University, in Halifax.
But marijuana makes it harder to judge distance and drivers
often tailgate and swerve from lane to lane, which cuts down their
reaction time and leads to crashes, he explained.
Although the extent of the problem isn't known, some studies
have found that 5 percent of people report driving after using
marijuana; and for those under age 25, as many as 20 percent,
Studies on the effect of driving under the influence of
marijuana have had mixed results, he said.
"There were some studies finding that cannabis actually had a negative association with crash risk, so people were actually safer using cannabis driving than when they weren't, but these were poorly designed studies," Asbridge said.
"So our study gives some clarity to the issue in showing a doubling of the risk in the very best studies that are out there and adds some level of justification to existing policies that restrict drug-impaired driving," he said.
The report was published in the Feb. 10 online edition of the
To see how marijuana affected driving, Asbridge's team reviewed
nine studies that included more than 49,000 people. This process --
called a meta-analysis -- looks for patterns across studies.
The researchers found that those driving under the influence of
marijuana were nearly twice as likely to have a car crash as those
who were not under the influence.
Studies outside the review have shown that drivers aged 35 and
younger are more likely to have car accidents after using
marijuana, the authors noted.
"These findings reaffirm many of our accepted understandings regarding acute cannabis intoxication and psychomotor performance," said Paul Armentano, deputy director of NORML (the National Organization for the Reform of Marijuana Laws). "That is why operating a motor vehicle while acutely impaired by cannabis is presently a criminal offense in all 50 states."
This risk appears to be greatest in less-experienced cannabis
users, younger drivers, and among those who combine the use of
cannabis and alcohol, Armentano pointed out.
"That said, it should further be noted that cannabis-induced changes in performance are typically subtle, short-lived and less dramatic in more experienced cannabis consumers, who appear to develop tolerance to some of the drug's behavioral effects," he added.
"Further, this overall elevated risk is far less than the elevated risk of accidents associated with the consumption of alcohol, including its use in legal quantities," Armentano said.
While some suggest that drivers should be tested for marijuana,
so far, no effective test exists that can be done at a traffic stop
to accurately pinpoint when a driver used the drug.
"This evidence makes a case for introducing policies to reduce cannabis-impaired driving," said Wayne Hall, from the University of Queensland Centre for Clinical Research in Brisbane, Australia. He wrote an accompanying editorial for the journal.
He said that roadside drug testing, such as that used for
alcohol, may be a useful approach.
But there are no handy devices, such as a breathalyzer, to tell
if someone has recently used marijuana, Asbridge noted.
"The challenge is defining a level that equates with impairment. A number of countries have already introduced roadside testing by deciding that any detectable evidence of recent use constitutes impaired driving. However, we do not know how effective testing has been because the policy has not been evaluated," Hall said.
Another expert outlined the problems with such tests.
"Because THC, the active ingredient in marijuana, can be detected several weeks after use of marijuana, it is hard to determine with certainty if a driver testing positive for marijuana is indeed impaired by the substance at the time of testing," said Dr. Guohua Li, a professor of epidemiology at Columbia University in New York City.
So more research is needed. "This issue is especially urgent and
important in light of the ongoing epidemic of drugged driving and
increased permissibility and availability of marijuana worldwide,"
While recognition that driving under the influence of marijuana
is a problem is a first step in finding ways to curb it, Jan
Withers, national president of Mothers Against Drunk Driving
(MADD), stated that "drunk driving remains the primary threat to
our families on the road."
However, she added, "this study underscores the importance of
the work that MADD is doing to support people who have been
victimized by drugged driving and recognize law-enforcement's
efforts to pioneer effective strategies to stop drugged driving.
Notably, it shows the increased danger posed by those drivers using
both alcohol and drugs."
For more about drugged driving, visit the
U.S. National Institute on Drug Abuse.
Copyright © 2012
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.