Stents No Better Than Medicine for Stable Heart Disease,
MONDAY, Feb. 27 (HealthDay News) -- Many people with stable
heart disease undergo an expensive artery-opening procedure when
medication would work just as well, a new study suggests.
The procedure involves placing a tiny mesh stent, or tube, in a
clogged artery. As many as three-quarters of these operations are
unnecessary, said lead researcher Dr. David L. Brown, a professor
of medicine at Stony Brook University Medical Center in New
Money is the driving force, Brown said. "Everybody gets paid to
put in stents, the hospital gets paid, the doctor gets paid, the
stenting company gets paid," he said. "It's how our fee-for-service
environment has taken over the decision making of this branch of
Stenting costs an average of $9,500 more to the patient over a
lifetime compared with medication, Brown said. Although the
procedure, called percutaneous coronary intervention, reduces death
and future heart attacks for someone actually having a heart
attack, its use in stable heart disease patients is questionable,
For the study, published Feb. 27 in the
Archives of Internal Medicine, Brown and Dr. Kathleen Stergiopoulos, an associate professor of clinical medicine at Stony Brook, analyzed eight trials involving more than 7,000 patients randomly assigned to medical therapy or stenting plus medication. The trials were begun between 1997 and 2005.
In this type of study, called a meta-analysis, researchers look
for patterns that might not have been the main intent of the
During an average follow-up of more than four years, no
significant differences were seen in longevity or quality of
Overall, 649 patients died, 322 who received stents and 327 who
received medication alone, the study found. Nonfatal heart attacks
were suffered by 323 patients with stents and 291 taking only
Among those with stents, 774 needed new procedures to open
blocked heart arteries. Among those on medical therapy, 1,049 also
needed a procedure to open blocked arteries.
Of more than 4,000 patients for whom data on chest pain --
called angina -- was available, 29 percent of those with stents had
persistent chest pain compared with 33 percent of those on medical
therapy alone, Brown found.
There is no data that stenting patients with stable heart
disease reduces the risk of dying or having a heart attack, Brown
"This is not to say no one will need stenting, but only about a third of patients treated initially with medical therapy will need to cross over to stenting," he said.
"People shouldn't blindly agree to have procedures unless the doctor can tell them that there is a documented benefit" in quality or length of life, he said.
Quality of life involves relief of chest pains, he said. If
patients on the best medication still have chest pain that is
unacceptable to them, stenting becomes appropriate, Brown said.
Medical therapy included aspirin to prevent clotting, beta
blockers and ACE inhibitors or angiotensin receptor blockers to
control blood pressure, and statins to lower cholesterol, the
"If you go the medical therapy route, it means the patient has to be followed in an outpatient environment to see how they are responding to the medical therapy, and that takes time and effort that doesn't reimburse very well," he said. "That's part of the equation that drives putting in a stent rather than following the patient on medical therapy."
Dr. James Blankenship, a spokesman for the Society for
Cardiovascular Angiography and Interventions, wasn't surprised by
"This is largely old news and many interventional cardiologists are avoiding the pitfalls that the authors are pointing out," he said. "In fact, the volume of interventions among Medicare patients has gone down 18 percent between 2005 and 2010."
"For many people, conservative medical therapy is the right thing, but for those who have a lot of symptoms, having a coronary intervention is a reasonable strategy," he said.
Dr. Gregg C. Fonarow, co-director of the University of
California, Los Angeles Preventive Cardiology Program at the David
Geffen School of Medicine, agreed that medical therapy is the first
choice for patients with stable heart disease.
Coronary stenting should be reserved for those patients who have
worsening symptoms despite optimal medical therapy, he said.
For patients with stable coronary artery disease, "the most
effective and valuable therapy to prevent disease progression,
heart attacks, stroke, heart failure and premature cardiovascular
death is a combination of medications together with lifestyle
modification," Fonarow added.
For more information on heart disease, visit the
American Heart Association.
Copyright © 2012
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.