'Watch and Wait' Approach Often Best for Older Patients With Kidney Cancer 02/13/13
TUESDAY, Feb. 12 (HealthDay News) -- Sometimes, simply watching
and waiting is a safe alternative to surgery for older patients
with small kidney tumors, a new study suggests.
"Physicians can comfortably tell an elderly patient, especially a patient that is not healthy enough to tolerate general anesthesia and surgery, that the likelihood of dying of kidney cancer is low and that kidney surgery is unlikely to extend their lives," study lead author Dr. William Huang, an assistant professor of urologic oncology at NYU Medical Center, said in a news release from the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO).
The findings are to be presented Saturday at an ASCO conference
in New York City. Research presented at medical meetings is
typically considered preliminary until published in a peer-reviewed
In their study, Huang's team analyzed data from more than 8,300
patients aged 66 and older who were diagnosed with small kidney
tumors (less than 1.5 inches in diameter). Of those patients, 70
percent had surgery to remove either a part of the kidney or the
entire organ and 31 percent underwent surveillance with imaging
such as MRI, ultrasound and CT.
Over nearly five years of follow-up, 25 percent of the patients
died from all causes and three percent of the patients died of
kidney cancer. The rates of kidney cancer death were the same for
patients who had surgery and those who underwent surveillance.
However, the study found patients in the surveillance group had
a much lower risk of death from any cause, as well as a lower risk
of having cardiovascular problems such as heart failure, stroke or
Huang stressed, however, that some patients may still prefer a
surgical approach. "Since it is difficult to identify which tumors
will become lethal, elderly patients who are completely healthy and
have an extended life expectancy, may opt for surgery," he
The researchers also found that the percentage of patients with
small kidney tumors who were managed with surveillance increased
between 25 percent to 37 percent from 2000 to 2007. This suggests
that doctors are becoming more aware that small kidney tumors may
not pose a threat, even if they are cancerous, the study authors
Two experts working with kidney cancer patients agreed that a
"watch and wait" approach may be suitable for some patients.
The study "reaffirms the growing understanding that small
[kidney] masses are relatively slow growing and generally pose only
a small risk especially in the elderly population," said Dr. Manish
Vira, director of the fellowship program in urologic oncology at
North Shore LIJ's Arthur Smith Institute for Urology, in Lake
However, he noted that "although the risk is small, it is not
zero as demonstrated by the finding that 3 percent [of the patients
in the study] died of kidney cancer."
"It would interesting to look at these patients to determine if there are specific risk factors that predict more aggressive behavior of these small masses," Vira said. "This would allow physicians to target treatment for those patients with small [kidney] masses who are at higher risk."
Dr. Matthew Galsky is director of genitourinary medical oncology
at the Tisch Cancer Institute at Mount Sinai School of Medicine, in
New York City. He said prior studies "have shown that small kidney
tumors that are not removed grow relatively slowly (approximately
0.3-0.4 centimeters per year) and in one series, only 1 percent of
such tumors spread to other places in the body."
Galsky said the new study did have some limitations -- it was
retrospective, looking over past data rather than the "gold
standard" prospective form of trial -- and the methods of
surveillance (such as scans) for the patients who did not get
surgery was not made clear.
Nevertheless, he said, the findings, "should allow clinicians
and patients to feel more comfortable about surveillance,
particularly for the 'oldest old' and those patients with multiple
[other health conditions] that would make surgery especially high
The National Kidney Foundation has more about
Copyright © 2013
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.