Public Funding Spurs Couples to Seek Fertility Treatment05/16/13
WEDNESDAY, May 15 (HealthDay News) -- Public funding of assisted
reproductive technology, including in vitro fertilization (IVF)
treatments, broadens the range of couples who seek treatment for
infertility by attracting a more diverse population, according to
new research from Canada.
When the province of Quebec began to fund up to three cycles of
IVF in August 2010, researchers compared patients who sought that
treatment before and after the mandate.
Afterward, "we found larger numbers of lower income, less
well-educated, unemployed people seeking fertility treatment," said
Phyllis Zelkowitz, director of research in the department of
psychiatry and senior investigator at the Lady Davis Institute of
the Jewish General Hospital, in Montreal.
The study is published in the May 16
New England Journal of Medicine.
For the study, Zelkowitz and her colleagues compared data on
nearly 3,600 couples. Of those, 436 sought treatment before the
policy change, 821 immediately after and 2,316 eight months after
the policy change.
The investigators found the proportion of treated couples with
college degrees declined from 68 percent to 63 percent eight months
later. Unemployed couples seeking treatment rose from 3.6 percent
to 11.6 percent. And the proportion of patients with household
incomes of $65,000 a year or less increased from about 37 percent
to more than 47 percent.
For white couples, the proportion dropped from about 67 percent
to 63 percent in the eight-month period, after rising immediately
after the policy change.
Zelkowitz also found the rate of couples seeking treatment for
secondary infertility doubled from 14 percent to 29 percent.
Secondary infertility means being unable to get pregnant or carry a
pregnancy to term after having one or more biological children.
The mandated policy change came with stipulations, Zelkowitz
said. It approved coverage for up to three treatment cycles of IVF.
It mandated the transfer of only one embryo per treatment cycle,
with a goal of reducing preterm births, she noted.
Preterm births are more common with multiple pregnancies and are
riskier to the babies, experts agree.
"One of the goals of the funding was to reduce preterm births, and they have already done that," Zelkowitz said.
The study findings are in conflict with earlier U.S. studies,
which have shown that even when patients have access to public
funding for assisted reproductive technology, barriers continue to
exist, including social, economic and ethnic obstacles. As a
result, these earlier studies suggested, the typical patients
remain older, wealthier, more-educated white couples.
In the United States, infertility affects about one of eight
women of reproductive age and their partners, according to the
American Society for Reproductive Medicine.
Currently, 15 states have passed laws that mandate insurers to
cover or offer coverage for infertility diagnosis and treatment,
but some states exclude coverage for IVF.
Assisted reproductive technology is typically defined as
fertility treatments in which both eggs and sperm are handled, such
as IVF, but not procedures such as taking medicine to stimulate egg
production, according to the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and
Only about 5 percent of infertile couples need assisted
reproductive technology, the society estimates.
For others, egg stimulation or lifestyle changes such as losing
weight or stopping smoking can help them achieve a pregnancy.
However, for those who do need IVF, the cost can be prohibitive.
A cycle of IVF costs about $12,400, the society estimates.
The study findings about patient demographics changing after
public funding became available do not surprise Dr. Wendy
Schillings, a fertility specialist in Allentown, Pa. When she meets
patients who have only diagnosis covered, she said, they often
delay treatment if they need IVF, hoping to save up the money
Couples who don't have IVF coverage often ask for more embryos
to be transferred, she said, and she then counsels them on the
risks of multiple births.
"Absolutely lower-income couples can do it [seek treatment] and will do it," Schillings said. However, for those with higher incomes, the decision may involve fewer sacrifices, she added.
To learn more about infertility coverage, state by state, visit
National Conference of State Legislatures.
Copyright © 2013
. All rights reserved.
Please be aware that this information is provided to supplement the care provided by your physician. It is neither intended nor implied to be a substitute for professional medical advice. CALL YOUR HEALTHCARE PROVIDER IMMEDIATELY IF YOU THINK YOU MAY HAVE A MEDICAL EMERGENCY. Always seek the advice of your physician or other qualified health provider prior to starting any new treatment or with any questions you may have regarding a medical condition.